24 November, 2019

I don’t know !

It takes guts to say that “I don’t know” but trust me the world opens up for you. Human beings find it intolerable to say it to themselves or to the group that ‘they do not know’. Right from our childhood we keep getting sermons that we should know. If someone in public tell you with utter intense surprise, don’t you know this ? I am sure it makes you feel, not okay, may be for some time. Not to know is not a desirable state that we all look forward. All attempts are being made to project or confabulate that ‘I know’. There is lot of pressure that we carry just to show that, we know.

The world is full of people who would leave no stone unturned to make you feel that they know more than you. Lot of their energy is directed towards establishing their superiority of knowing more. We all have heard of a story, there was a man of wisdom, who used to put a belt around his stomach, ensuring that the knowledge inside should not out move. People complicate their life in thousand ways, just to stay in this utopia of the knowing more.

On the other side are the people who unnecessarily think that other know more. Some of them are political while many unaware. We tend to see the first type more in the corporate world. Don’t you remember the last meeting where, one of your colleague was unstoppable, irritating everybody around ? The person kept continuously stating points that the team was already well aware of. He was influencing the senior officers who had come from the Corporate Office.

Haven’t you also done something like this? Speaking in the meeting to position yourself as
knowledgeable. Some individuals carry this fear of not knowing to the extent of being anxious and this could lead to strange behaviors. I have seen committee members in interview who test their knowledge, instead of the applicant knowledge. Not sure, they interview to select or reject.

None of the behavior mentioned above would ever bring new knowing, hence the knowing is generally low. Behavior do not change, principles are not understood and ignored, short term is killing the long term, just because of ego – ‘I know’.

When the leaders in the organisation are not able to appreciate the value of ‘I don’t know, or
stay aware that they are always in the process of knowing. Organisations also start getting in to the, ‘I know’ syndrome. You will see this view settling in to the cultural fabric of the organisation over a period of time. Organisation will stop seeing the emerging and the fallacy of ‘knowing’ will manifest in the dwindling growth. Leadership even, after this may not be able to see, organisation also may not recognize the opportunities or threat and end starts approached faster.

It is said that once you define a tree as mango or banana tree, you stop observing it. You would tend to miss the small new leaf, the fruit bud or many other smaller changes. The point is when you carry the notion that you know you stop learning, you stop experimenting, or you take it for granted. MD of one of the organisation that I earlier worked with would take no time to say that ‘ He does not know’.

Everything becomes simply open to knowing, when you say; I don’t know!

13 November, 2019

Deregulating Deposit Insurance

Deposit insurance is a measure implemented in many countries to protect bank depositors, in full or in part, from losses caused by a bank's inability to pay its debts when due. Deposit insurance systems are one component of a financial system safety net that promotes financial stability.

Banks are allowed (and often encouraged) to lend or invest most of the money deposited with them instead of safe-keeping the full amounts (see fractional-reserve banking). If many of a bank's borrowers fail to repay their loans when due, the bank's creditors, including its depositors, risk loss. Because they rely on customer deposits that can be withdrawn on little or no notice, banks in financial trouble are prone to bank runs, where depositors seek to withdraw funds quickly ahead of a possible bank insolvency. Because banking institution failures have the potential to trigger a broad spectrum of harmful events, including economic recessions, policy makers maintain deposit insurance schemes to protect depositors and to give them comfort that their funds are not at risk.

Deposit insurance institutions are for the most part government run or established, and may or may not be a part of a country's central bank, while some are private entities with government backing or completely private entities. There are a number of countries with more than one deposit insurance system in operation including Austria, Canada (Ontario & Quebec), Germany, Italy, and the United States.

India introduced Deposit Insurance in 1962. The Deposit Insurance Corporation commenced functioning on January 1, 1962 under the aegis of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). 1971 witnessed the establishment of another institution, the Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. (CGCI). In 1978, the DIC and the CGCI were merged to form the Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC). Broad contours of the deposit insurance scheme of DICGC are as follows; 

1. Which banks are insured by the DICGC ?
a). Commercial Banks : All commercial banks including branches of foreign banks functioning in India, local area banks and regional rural banks are insured by the DICGC.
b). Cooperative Banks : All State, Central and Primary cooperative banks, also called urban cooperative banks, functioning in States / Union Territories which have amended the local Cooperative Societies Act empowering the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to order the Registrar of Cooperative Societies of the State / Union Territory to wind up a cooperative bank or to supersede its committee of management and requiring the Registrar not to take any action regarding winding up, amalgamation or reconstruction of a co-operative bank without prior sanction in writing from the RBI are covered under the Deposit Insurance Scheme. At present all co-operative banks are covered by the DICGC.
Primary cooperative societies are not insured by the DICGC.

2. What does the DICGC insure? The DICGC insures all deposits such as savings, fixed, current, recurring, etc. deposits except the following types of deposits
i). Deposits of foreign Governments;
ii). Deposits of Central/State Governments;
iii). Inter-bank deposits;
iv). Deposits of the State Land Development Banks with the State co-operative bank;
v). Any amount due on account of and deposit received outside India
vi). Any amount, which has been specifically exempted by the corporation with the previous approval of the Reserve Bank of India

3. What is the maximum deposit amount insured by the DICGC?
Each depositor in a bank is insured upto a maximum of Rs.5,00,000 (Rupees Five Lakh) for both principal and interest amount held by him in the same right and same capacity as on the date of liquidation/cancellation of bank's licence or the date on which the scheme of amalgamation / merger / reconstruction comes into force.

4. How will you know whether your bank is insured by the DICGC or not?
The DICGC while registering the banks as insured banks furnishes them with printed leaflets for display giving information relating to the protection afforded by the Corporation to the depositors of the insured banks. In case of doubt, depositor should make specific enquiry from the branch official in this regard.

5. What is the ceiling on amount of Insured deposits kept by one person in different branches of a bank?
The deposits kept in different branches of a bank are aggregated for the purpose of insurance cover and a maximum amount upto Rupees Five lakh is paid.

6. Does the DICGC insure just the principal on an account or both principal and accrued interest?
The DICGC insures principal and interest upto a maximum amount of Rs.Five lakh. For example, if an individual had an account with a principal amount of Rs.95,000 plus accrued interest of Rs.4,000, the total amount insured by the DICGC would be Rs.99,000. If, however, the principal amount in that account was Rs. Five lakh, the accrued interest would not be insured, not because it was interest but because that was the amount over the insurance limit.

7. Can deposit insurance be increased by depositing funds into several different accounts at the same bank?
All funds held in the same type of ownership at the same bank are added together before deposit insurance is determined. If the funds are in different types of ownership or are deposited into separate banks they would then be separately insured.

8. Are deposits in different banks separately insured?
Yes. If you have deposits with more than one bank, deposit insurance coverage limit is applied separately to the deposits in each bank.

9. If I have my funds on deposit at two different banks, and those two banks are closed on the same day, are my funds added together, or insured separately?
Your funds from each bank would be insured separately, regardless of the date of closure.

10. What is the meaning of deposits held in the same capacity and same right; and deposits held in different capacities and different right?
If an individual opens more than one deposit account in one or more branches of a bank.
For example, Shri S.K. Pandit opens one or more savings/current account and one or more fixed/recurring deposit accounts etc., all these are considered as accounts held in the same capacity and in the same right. Therefore, the balances in all these accounts are aggregated and insurance cover is available upto rupees Five lakh in maximum.
If Shri S.K. Pandit also opens other deposit accounts in his capacity as a partner of a firm or guardian of a minor or director of a company or trustee of a trust or a joint account, say with his wife Smt. K. A. Pandit, in one or more branches of the bank then such accounts are considered as held in different capacity and different right. Accordingly, such deposits accounts will also enjoy the insurance cover upto rupees Five lakh separately.

It is further clarified that the deposit held in the name of the proprietary concern where a depositor is the sole proprietor and the amount of Deposit held in his individual capacity are aggregated and insurance cover is available upto rupees Five lakh in maximum.

Deposits held in joint accounts (revised w.e.f. April 26, 2007)
If more than one deposit accounts (Savings, Current, Recurring or Fixed deposit) are jointly held by individuals in one or more branch of a bank say three individuals A, B & C hold more than one joint deposit accounts in which their names appear in the same order then all these accounts are considered as held in the same capacity and in the same right. Accordingly, balances held in all these accounts will be aggregated for the purpose of determining the insured amount within the limit of Rs.1 lakh.
However, if individuals open more than one joint accounts in which their names are not in the same order for example, A, B and C; C, B and A; C, A and B; A, C and B; or group of persons are different say A, B and C and A, B and D etc. then, the deposits held in these joint accounts are considered as held in the different capacity and different right. Accordingly, insurance cover will be available separately upto rupees Five lakh to every such joint account where the names appearing in different order or names are different.

11. Can the bank deduct the amount of dues payable by the depositor?
Yes. Banks have the right to set off their dues from the amount of deposits. The deposit insurance is available after netting of such dues.

12. Who pays the cost of deposits insurance?
Deposit insurance premium is borne entirely by the insured bank.

13. When is the DICGC liable to pay?
If a bank goes into liquidation:The DICGC is liable to pay to each depositor through the liquidator, the amount of his deposit upto Rupees Five lakh within two months from the date of receipt of claim list from the liquidator.
If a bank is reconstructed or amalgamated / merged with another bank: The DICGC pays the bank concerned, the difference between the full amount of deposit or the limit of insurance cover in force at the time, whichever is less and the amount received by him under the reconstruction / amalgamation scheme within two months from the date of receipt of claim list from the transferee bank / Chief Executive Officer of the insured bank/transferee bank as the case may be.

14. Does the the DICGC directly deal with the depositors of failed banks?
No. In the event of a bank's liquidation, the liquidator prepares depositor wise claim list and sends it to the DICGC for scrutiny and payment. The DICGC pays the money to the liquidator who is liable to pay to the depositors. In the case of amalgamation / merger of banks, the amount due to each depositor is paid to the transferee bank.

15. Can any insured bank withdraw from the the DICGC coverage?
No. The deposit insurance scheme is compulsory and no bank can withdraw from it.

16. Can the DICGC withdraw deposit insurance coverage from any bank?
The Corporation may cancel the registration of an insured bank if it fails to pay the premium for three consecutive periods. In the event of the DICGC withdrawing its coverage from any bank for default in the payment of premium the public will be notified through newspapers.
Registration of an insured bank stands cancelled if the bank is prohibited from receiving fresh deposits; or its licence is cancelled or a licence is refused to it by the RBI; or it is wound up either voluntarily or compulsorily; or it ceases to be a banking company or a co-operative bank within the meaning of Section 36A(2) of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949; or it has transferred all its deposit liabilities to any other institution; or it is amalgamated with any other bank or a scheme of compromise or arrangement or of reconstruction has been sanctioned by a competent authority and the said scheme does not permit acceptance of fresh deposits. In the event of the cancellation of registration of a bank, the deposits of the bank remain covered by the insurance till the date of the cancellation.

17. What will be the Corporation's liability to the banks on de-registration.
The Corporation has deposit insurance liability on liquidation etc. of "Insured banks" i.e. banks which have been de-registered (a) on account of prohibition on receiving fresh deposits or (b) on cancellation of license or it is found that license can not be granted. The liability of the Corporation in these cases is limited to the extent of deposits as on the date of cancellation of registration of bank as an insured bank.
On liquidation etc. of other de-registered banks i.e. banks which have been de-registered on other grounds such as non payment of premium or their ceasing to be eligible co-operative banks under section 2(gg) of the DICGC Act, 1961, the Corporation will have no liability.

The above deposit insurance scheme suffers from the following infirmities.
i). The maximum coverage in the scheme is Rs.5.00 Lakh, which was fixed few years ago.
ii). With the deregulation of interest rates, which can be offered by the different financial institutions / banks, usually small & / or weak FI’s offer higher interest rates. The individual depositor is ill equipped to assess  the strength of FI, and with the allurement of higher rate of interest, under the impression that FI’s are RBI regulated entities, (Though regulatory control of RBI is not upto the desired standards. Huge NPA’s in the banking system, Sharda Chit fund scam & PMC bank are glaring examples of failures of regulatory control of RBI), falls into the  trap of poorly managed banks / FI’s.

I am of the view that “Deposit Insurance” should not be restricted to the DICGC, and be allowed to be underwritten by the general insurance companies also, as any other insurance product. This will have the following advantages;
i). A Depositor will be able to get insurance cover for his entire deposits.
ii). A depositor will be able to get better rates of interest without any risk. For example big nationalized bank (SBI) offering certain rate of interest, say, “X %” , and a cooperative bank is offering “ X + 1.00 %”, with deposit insurance premium of say 0.5%, the depositor will be gainer by 0.5%.
iii). This will create an atmosphere of self regulation in the financial sector, as the credibility of a financial institution will be judged by the insurance premium quoted by the insurance company. 
iv). Better managed small FI’s will be able to get deposits on finer terms.
v). As various financial instruments, such as deposits with the banks , cooperative banks, NBFC’s, Corporate bonds etc,  will be backed by insurance, this will help create vibrant financial market.


'Disclaimer: The sole purpose of this blog is to create awareness on the subject and must not be used as a guide for taking or recommending any action or decision. A reader must do his own research and seek professional advice if he intends to take any action or decision in the matters covered in this blog